Which is worse?

I don't feel like making a post, so which do you think is worse?

Twilight or Eragon.

Remember this is the MOVIE, not the book.

Wow.. That is a tough choice.......................... Eragon was very little like the book, but at least it was an "ok" production with good effects ect... Twilight was NOTHING like the book and had HORRID effects...... I'd pick Eragon over Twiligth anyday.....

So you think Twilight's worse?

To speak my opinion:

Twilight seemed more like a fan-made version with more humor and different aspects on the setting and character personallity. I personally think some of the OOC quotes were made by Hollywood just to make some laughs.

Eragon, on the other hand, had a completely different ending, and the plot swayed away from the book quite alot. However, the effects were awesome, and the plot was clear and understanding, though alittle fast.

I still did not like Twilight due to the horrid graphics/character interpretations..

havnt seen twilit but eragon SUCKED. so i´d have to say eragon

never seen any...

I think neither of them should have been made into movies, both needed time that they didn't have (as in, they needed to be longer, but would have been too long if they added the time in), but I'd have to say Eragon was worse. Now, on the other hand, if I hadn't read the books, then I might have a different opinion. Twilight would have seemed waaay strange and no good if you watched it before you read the book - it would seem random and probably kind of plotless.

I disagree, I saw the movie first, and I'm reading the book now, I thought the movie was fine. but I did read eragon first, and I thought the movie was crap, and seemed really bad. And the way it was put together, makes it so they can't make eldest unless they change it a fair amount.

Darned witchcraft tales... killing our country's ethics from the inside out! I'll have none of it!

wtf, why'd you lock this Edgar?

Seriously? I don't see how you thought the movie was fine, Chris...I could barely sit through it without laughing and finding errors...

Sio wrote:Seriously? I don't see how you thought the movie was fine, Chris...I could barely sit through it without laughing and finding errors...

I hadn't read the book yet, I already said that

Good point. I'd be astounded finding the errors of the movie while reading though.

I basically hate all Books -> Movies.

I need to see Scott Pilgrim

Chris wrote:I basically hate all Books -> Movies.

I need to see Scott Pilgrim

Yes you do. It's actually decent!

And It'll give me Knives in Scott Pilgrim: The Game

Still waiting for Young Neil to be in it ):

We all are.

Indeed. Enough game talk though. Make a thread for it. Btw, the Scott Pilgrim movie is a good movie, but a bad interpretation of the comics.